Hokum Movie Review: Damian McCarthy’s Masterclass in Psychological Dread and Irish Folk Horror

Watch on YouTube

Hokum Movie Review: Damian McCarthy’s Masterclass in Psychological Dread and Irish Folk Horror

The Atmosphere of Unease: An Introduction

There is a specific type of silence that only exists in a Damian McCarthy film. It isn’t the absence of sound, but rather the heavy, expectant weight of something lurking just outside the frame. As I sat in the darkened screening room for Hokum, the latest offering from the Irish auteur behind the cult hits Caveat and Oddity, I found myself clutching the armrest before a single drop of blood was shed.

In the landscape of modern horror—often cluttered with loud jump scares and over-explained lore—McCarthy remains a minimalist surgeon. Hokum is a supernatural psychological thriller that dares to ask: what if the lies we tell to protect ourselves are the very things that invite the darkness in? Starring Adam Scott in a role that pivots sharply from his Severance persona, and featuring a haunting ensemble including Peter Coonan and David Wilmot, Hokum is not just a movie; it is a masterclass in atmospheric tension.

As the founder of Charotar Daily, I’ve watched the "elevated horror" trend wax and wane. However, McCarthy doesn't care about trends. He cares about the primal fear of the dark. In this review, we’ll dissect why Hokum is a landmark in 2025 cinema, evaluating its direction, technical prowess, and the chilling performances that make it an instant essential.

Direction and Screenplay: The Architecture of a Nightmare

Damian McCarthy, pulling double duty as writer and director, has a peculiar gift for "liminal horror." He understands that a hallway is scarier than a monster. In Hokum, he utilizes a non-linear narrative structure that keeps the audience in a state of perpetual disorientation.

The screenplay revolves around a protagonist (Scott) returning to a remote Irish estate under the guise of settling a family inheritance, only to find that the "Hokum"—the nonsense stories told by his ancestors—contains a terrifying, physical truth. McCarthy’s writing is lean. There is no "info-dumping." Instead, he uses visual cues—a rotting floorboard, a misaligned portrait, a recurring sound of a whistle—to build the mythology.

Compare this to his work in Oddity. While Oddity used a central, terrifying prop (the wooden man) to anchor the fear, Hokum is more cerebral. It reminds me of the psychological layering in Robert Eggers’ The Witch, where the environment itself feels like an antagonist. McCarthy’s direction is patient; he isn't afraid to let the camera linger on a closed door for ten seconds longer than a Hollywood editor would allow, forcing the viewer’s imagination to fill the void.

Performances: Adam Scott’s Darkest Turn Yet

When we think of Adam Scott, we often think of dry wit or corporate anxiety. In Hokum, Scott delivers a performance of profound vulnerability and burgeoning madness. He plays a man trying to rationalize the irrational. There is a specific scene in the second act—a quiet confrontation in a library—where Scott’s micro-expressions convey a man losing his grip on reality without saying a single word. It is a career-best performance that anchors the film’s more fantastical elements.

Peter Coonan and David Wilmot provide the local "color" that quickly turns pale. Wilmot, in particular, excels as a character who knows more than he’s letting on. His chemistry with Scott creates a friction that is more uncomfortable than any ghost story. The casting here is deliberate; these are "lived-in" faces that belong to the Irish soil, making the supernatural intrusions feel like a violation of a very real world.

Cinematography: The Art of the Shadow

Colm Hogan, the cinematographer, deserves an Oscar conversation for his work here. Shot on location in Ireland, the film avoids the "Grey-Slog" aesthetic common in modern thrillers. Instead, Hogan uses a palette of deep ochres, mossy greens, and a level of black-level depth that is rarely seen in digital cinematography.

The use of "negative space" is Hogan’s greatest weapon. In Hokum, the characters are often pushed to the far edge of the frame, leaving a vast, dark emptiness behind them. This visual storytelling informs the viewer that the protagonist is never truly alone. A standout sequence involves a lantern-lit trek through a subterranean cellar; the way the light spills across the damp stone walls creates a claustrophobic effect that had the entire theater holding its breath. For those interested in cinematography techniques in horror, Hokum is a textbook example of how to use lighting to drive a narrative.

Sound Design and Background Score: The Unheard Terror

If you’ve read my previous reviews on CharotarDaily.com, you know I believe sound is 50% of the horror experience. The score for Hokum is dissonant and experimental. It shuns the traditional orchestral swells in favor of mechanical hums, distorted folk instruments, and rhythmic thumping that mimics a heartbeat.

The editing, also overseen with McCarthy’s signature precision, uses "sound bridges" to link the past and the present. A scream in a flashback might transition into the teakettle’s whistle in the present day. This seamless integration of audio and visual elements ensures that the "dwell time" for the audience’s fear is maximized—there are no "safe" scenes where you can relax.

Comparative Analysis: Where Does 'Hokum' Stand?

To understand Hokum, one must look at the lineage of Irish Folk Horror. While films like The Banshees of Inisherin touched on the isolation of the landscape, Hokum leans into the malevolence of the folklore seen in The Hallow or You Are Not My Mother.

However, McCarthy’s work is more disciplined. Unlike the jump-scare-heavy Conjuring universe, Hokum shares DNA with the "slow-burn" mastery of Ari Aster’s Hereditary. Both films deal with familial trauma manifesting as the supernatural. Where McCarthy differs is in his sense of "trickery." As the title suggests, the film plays with the audience’s expectations. Just when you think you’ve solved the "Hokum," the rug is pulled out from under you in a third act that is as devastating as it is logical.

The Technical Edge: Why This Matters for Film Lovers

From a production standpoint, Hokum is a triumph for independent film production values. Produced by veterans like Roy Lee and Steven Schneider (who have their fingers on the pulse of modern horror), the film looks twice as expensive as its budget suggests. This is a testament to the "less is more" philosophy. By focusing on practical effects—a McCarthy staple—the film avoids the "uncanny valley" pitfalls of CGI monsters. When you see something in the shadows of Hokum, your brain recognizes it as a physical object, which triggers a much deeper fear response.

Final Verdict: A New Peak in Horror

Hokum is a rare beast. It is a film that respects the audience's intelligence while simultaneously terrifying them. It is a clinical study of guilt, wrapped in a chilling ghost story, and delivered with the visual flair of a seasoned master. Damian McCarthy has solidified himself as one of the most important voices in genre cinema today.

The film does have minor pacing issues in the middle—a slight "lull" as it sets up the final dominoes—but this is a small price to pay for the crescendo that follows. The ending will be debated in film circles for years to come; it is ambiguous, haunting, and perfectly aligned with the movie’s themes.

Rating: 4.5/5 Stars

Who Should Watch This?

• Fans of Psychological Dread: If you prefer The Babadook over Scream, this is your film.

• A24 Enthusiasts: While not an A24 release, it carries that same commitment to "vibe" and artistic integrity.

• Cinematography Nerds: Watch it on the biggest screen possible to appreciate Colm Hogan’s shadow work.

• Adam Scott Fans: See a side of the actor you’ve never seen before—raw, terrified, and intense.

Skip it if: You are looking for a "fun" horror movie with lots of blood and loud noises. Hokum is a movie that stays in your house long after you’ve left the theater.

Rasesh’s Pro-Tip for Viewers: Pay close attention to the background of the shots in the first 20 minutes. McCarthy hides several "clues" in plain sight that completely change the context of the ending.

For more exclusive film analysis and the latest industry news, keep following CharotarDaily.com—your home for credible, expert-driven cinema reviews.

---